Brought to you by MediaOS

Welcome to The Niche Fix. Each week, we will share insights from experts and professionals in the niche publishing industry. Have questions or thoughts about the industry? Reply to this email, and let’s chat!

But first…

We’re gearing up for some very exciting Niche Media events in 2026. Here’s what’s locked in so far:

Niche Media Conference — April 8–10, Orlando, Florida
Niche Leadership Summit — September 2–4, New Orleans, Louisiana

Don’t miss out, as right now is the best-priced ticket you’ll get. Sign up today at NicheMediaEvents.com.

Ryan Dohrn’s Sales Corner: Cutting Through the Clutter

If you feel like your emails are disappearing into the void, you’re not alone. Every buyer’s inbox looks like a digital garage sale: stuff everywhere, and they’re not sure what’s worth keeping.

But don’t panic. Ryan Dohrn says there’s a simple way to break through the noise: be relevant, brief, and consistent.

Let’s unpack it.

1. Be Relevant (a.k.a. Beat Stranger Danger)
Remember being told as a kid not to talk to strangers? Turns out, adults still don’t like it. So when you cold-email someone out of nowhere, you’re violating a deep, lifelong instinct. The fix: warm people up before you pitch them.

Ryan recommends using LinkedIn like a secret weapon. Follow your prospects, like their posts, and drop the occasional comment. When you do that, LinkedIn literally emails them with your name in the subject line. Boom—you’re no longer a stranger. You’re that nice person who liked their post about company culture.

2. Be Brief (No One Reads Your Novels)
The biggest sales sin is over-explaining. Your prospects don’t want your life story—they want a reason to care. Ryan’s “Rule of Three and Three” is the cure: three words in the subject line, three sentences max in the body.

Instead of writing:

“Hi Julie, I’d love to schedule a call to discuss how we can leverage your Q4 marketing opportunities…”

Try this:

“Hi Julie, I’ve been working with [similar clients]. Love to share a five-minute idea that could help you hit your goals.”

Short, relevant, and easy to read between meetings—or at least before their next Teams notification pops up.

3. Be Consistent (Persistence > Perfection)
Most salespeople stop after two or three tries. Don’t. Ryan says it takes six to eight touchpoints to get real traction. The key is to stay consistent without becoming annoying. Reach out every few business days with something new—different subject line, different hook, same friendly tone.

Consistency builds familiarity, and familiarity builds trust. Even if they don’t reply right away, your name will feel recognizable when they finally do.

Ryan sums it up like this: “Professionals have a strategy. Amateurs wing it.”

So build your plan. Keep your outreach relevant, brief, and consistent. And remember—spraying and praying is for amateurs. You’re better than that.

Now, let’s talk marketing…

The Best Ad Agency in Town Might Be Your Magazine

By Zach O’Brien

Here’s a fun little secret that isn’t so secret anymore: the smartest niche media companies are quietly turning into full-blown marketing agencies.

That’s right. The publishers who used to sell you a half-page ad next to a story about the local chili cookoff are now running digital campaigns, managing email funnels, writing your blog posts, and maybe even redesigning your website.

Welcome to the era of the publisher-agency hybrid.

Take Spotlight Media in Fargo, North Dakota. They publish about ten magazines—everything from business to sport to lifestyle—but that’s just the tip of the iceberg. Behind the scenes, they’re also running programmatic ads, building websites, managing social campaigns, and basically doing everything short of designing your logo on a trucker hat.

It’s not a side hustle. It’s the future.

Why Everyone’s Suddenly an “Agency”

Marketers are exhausted. They’ve got one vendor for print, one for social, one for Google ads, and one that keeps insisting the metaverse is about to be huge (it’s not).

So when a publisher walks in and says, “Hey, what if you just worked with us for everything?” — it’s music to their overstimulated ears.

Paul Hoefer from Spotlight puts it best: they don’t sell ads; they sell solutions. Instead of pushing space in a magazine, they figure out what a client actually needs and build a plan that hits every angle. Print, digital, social, email—whatever works.

The goal? Make it so easy, the client forgets they ever had other vendors.

Ads Are Branding. Sponsored Content Is Conversion.

Let’s be real: most banner ads these days are basically the marketing version of a logo high-five. They’re good for awareness, for keeping your brand visible, for making sure people think, “Oh yeah, that company still exists.”

But if a client wants clicks, leads, or engagement? That’s where sponsored content and social campaigns crush it.

A story published by a trusted local media brand carries way more credibility than a company yelling “We’re the best!” on its own feed. Spotlight’s team writes and designs that content, runs it in their magazines and newsletters, and then chops it up for social posts and retargeting ads. One story, ten ways to win.

The Magic Formula

Here’s how to copy the Spotlight playbook (and probably make your sales team fall in love with you):

• Package, don’t piecemeal. Stop letting clients argue about print vs. digital. Sell them both. You’re Switzerland, but with ad revenue.

• Lead with discovery. Ask what they want before you pitch what you have. Radical concept, I know.

• Build a content studio. You already know how to tell stories—start telling your advertisers’ stories, too.

• Match the goal to the channel. Branding = banners. Conversions = sponsored content or paid social. Nobody wins when you mix that up.

• Be easy to work with. One invoice. One contact. Zero confusion.

The result? Bigger contracts, longer relationships, and clients who finally stop ghosting you every Q4.

The Big Picture

For decades, publishers have been the storytellers. The difference now is that we’re also the megaphone, the strategy, and the follow-up email.

So yes, it’s true. The hottest trend in media is publishers becoming agencies. But honestly? We were made for this. We already know the audience, we already know how to build trust, and we’ve been selling storytelling since before “content marketing” was even a thing.

The next time an advertiser says, “We need an agency,” you can smile and say, “Good news. You already have one.”

This issue of the Niche Fix is brought to you by MediaOS

MediaOS is the all-in-one platform built to power today’s media businesses—from publishers and content creators to event organizers. With tools for CDP, ad sales, production, accounting, reporting, and campaign management, MediaOS helps teams streamline operations, collaborate more effectively, and grow revenue across both audience and advertisers.

Now featuring a powerful new audience customer data platform for 1st party data and digital audience engagement with Fulfillment and Circulation Services Integrated with Strategic Fulfillment Group (SFG). MediaOS now supports full-service solutions for B2B and B2C publishers, associations, and membership-based organizations—including subscription management, issue mailing, telemarketing, conference orders, digital access, and premium distribution.

Whether you’re managing print magazines, digital content, or live events, MediaOS gives you everything you need to run your business smarter, faster, and with less manual effort.

Let's Connect!

New to the newsletter? Subscribe for free.

Are you following Niche? You can find our content on Instagram, Facebook, LinkedIn, and X.