Brought to you by Publication Printers

Welcome to The Niche Fix. Each week, we will share insights from experts and professionals in the niche publishing industry. Have questions or thoughts about the industry? Reply to this email, and let’s chat!

But first…

Don’t forget to include Niche Media Events into your 2026 budget.

Here’s what’s locked in so far:

Niche Media Conference — April 8–10, Orlando, Florida
Niche Leadership Summit — September 2–4, New Orleans, Louisiana

We’re making 2026 our best year yet. Hope to see you there!

Ryan Dohrn’s Sales Corner: How to Stop Getting “I’ll Pass” Emails

If your prospects keep replying with “Thanks, I’ll pass,” you’re not alone. It’s one of the most common, and avoidable, replies in sales.

According to Ryan Dohrn, it usually means one of two things: you’re not offering enough value, or you’re giving too much information.

1. You’re Not Showing Enough Value
Every email or voicemail should answer one question: Why should they reply to me?

Ryan recommends a simple three-sentence email structure:

• Start with credibility: “I’m working with Company A and Company B, and they’re loving the results.”

• Offer clear value: “I saw you’re promoting X on your site — I’d love to help you get more engagement around that.”

• Respect their time: “Can we chat for five minutes?”

When you don’t specify a short meeting time, prospects assume you want an hour. Be specific and brief.

2. You’re Giving Too Much Away
Many sales emails fail because they include every detail up front. If your email reads like a sales sheet — “Our home guide deadline is tomorrow, great rates available!” — you’ve already given them enough to decide no.

Don’t send PDFs or full pitches. Tease the idea instead. Your goal isn’t to close the deal in the email, it’s to spark curiosity and earn a conversation.

The Fix
Keep your outreach short, relevant, and valuable. Show credibility, highlight what’s in it for them, and make the next step easy.

As Ryan says, “You don’t want them making a decision before you’ve even had a chance to talk.”

Now, let’s talk clicks…

The Death of the Click: Why Banner Ads Are for Branding, Not Conversions

By Zach O’Brien

Once upon a time, the click was king. It was the coin of the digital realm, the metric marketers worshiped, the number you flashed in PowerPoints to prove you were winning the internet.

But here we are, two decades later, and most publishers finally agree on something: clicks don’t mean much. They don’t equal trust. They don’t equal attention. And they definitely don’t equal money.

Yet somehow, “clicks” remain the first metric many advertisers look at when evaluating a campaign. It is the equivalent of judging a first date by the handshake.

The Click Mirage

Click-through rates on digital ads are now so low that if you were hitting baseballs instead of impressions, you would be benched before the second inning. A 0.08% CTR is somehow considered “strong performance.”

Let’s be honest. Nobody clicks banner ads on purpose. The only reason anyone ever clicks one is because their finger slipped while trying to close it.

So why do we still sell them like they matter? Because it is simple. Because clients love charts. Because somewhere, buried deep in a spreadsheet, “clicks” make us feel productive.

But clicks are attention’s empty calories. All dopamine, no nutrition.

Branding Is the Real Job of Banner Ads

Here is the truth: banner ads, whether on your website or in your newsletter, are not conversion tools anymore. They are branding tools. They remind the audience who you are, they keep your logo in circulation, and they reinforce credibility. That is their job.

If marketers want actual conversions, they are better off investing in sponsored content or sponsored social campaigns that tell a story and create a call to action. Sponsored content drives engagement because it educates and entertains. Sponsored social drives clicks because it is native to the environment where people actually interact. Banners, on the other hand, do not exist to make people act. They exist to make people remember.

Sell the Steak, Not the Sizzle

The smartest niche publishers have started selling something better: time well spent.

They focus on the metrics that actually matter—engagement depth, scroll time, newsletter open consistency, event participation, and repeat visits. These are the numbers that show people care, not just that they exist.

It is a shift from vanity metrics to value metrics. From impressions to impact. As one publisher told me recently, “Clicks are a short fling. Engagement is the marriage.”

And advertisers are catching on. They want to be aligned with credibility, not clutter. If you can prove that your audience actually reads, listens, or interacts, even if the total number is smaller, you win. Relevance beats reach every time.

The Anti-Click Sales Pitch

So how do you sell in a world where “traffic” is no longer the headline stat? You tell a better story.

Instead of “We delivered 100,000 impressions,” you say:

• “Our readers spent an average of six minutes with this article and scrolled 92% of the way down the page.”

• “Our event attendees are 78% decision-makers who directly purchase or recommend your product.”

• “Our newsletter has a 48% open rate and the same names open every week.”

Now you are not selling pixels. You are selling behavior, loyalty, and trust.

The Future Is Fewer, Better Metrics

Vanity metrics are not dying because of new technology. They are dying because everyone is finally bored of pretending they matter.

The future of niche publishing is about curating insights that prove the value of connection, not the illusion of scale.

Because the best publishers are not chasing attention. They are earning it. And that is one metric you cannot fake.

This issue of the Niche Fix is brought to you by Publication Printers

For over 40 years, Publication Printers has been a trusted partner in the printing industry. Delivering exceptional results for magazines, catalogs, brochures, direct mail, digital editions, and more.

They’re proud to offer end-to-end solutions, managing every detail of your project—from printing and binding to mailing and shipping. Partner with them to bring your vision to life with unmatched quality and expertise.

Let's Connect!

New to the newsletter? Subscribe for free.

Are you following Niche? You can find our content on Instagram, Facebook, LinkedIn, and X.